Skip to main content

Buffalo Trace brings back old-timey whiskey brands not seen since Prohibition

Don't miss the Buffalo Trace Prohibition Collection

ff
Buffalo Trace

When it comes to bourbon (and American whiskey in general) there are few names more well-respected than Buffalo Trace. Obviously, Jack Daniel’s, Jim Beam, and even Wild Turkey are more well-known. But none of them have the accolades and enthusiastic fanbase of Buffalo Trace. Makers of iconic whiskeys like Eagle Rare, Weller, Stagg, Blanton’s, E.H. Taylor, and even Van Winkle, Buffalo Trace is unrivaled in the American whiskey world. But those aren’t even the only whiskeys produced under the Buffalo Trace whiskey umbrella.

The fact that this distillery seems to make nothing but award-winning whiskeys is why we were so excited when we heard that the brand is releasing a line of whiskeys it’s calling “The Prohibition Collection” this month. This new, annual limited-edition collection was created to pay tribute to the various whiskeys that were produced by the then-called George T. Stagg Distillery during Prohibition.

Yes, you read that right. The brand that’s now known as Buffalo Trace made and sold whiskey between 1920 and 1933 when Prohibition (with the ratification of the 18th Amendment to the Constitution) made the production, sale, and transportation illegal in the United States. This is because many doctors believed that whiskey could cure various ailments (hence doctors prescribing hot toddies in Scotland, England, and beyond as well). The U.S. government granted licenses to a few distilleries to make whiskey for medical purposes. This included George T. Stagg.

The Prohibition-era whiskeys being released in “The Prohibition Collection” are the formerly defunct Old Stagg, Golden Wedding, Three Feathers, Walnut Hill, and George T. Stagg Spiritus Frumenti.

  • Old Stagg is a barrel-proof, uncut, unfiltered bourbon.
  • Golden Wedding is a 107-proof whiskey.
  • Three Feathers is a 100-proof botted-in-bind whiskey.
  • Walnut Hill is a 90-proof high-rye bourbon.
  • George T. Stagg Distillery Spiritus Frumenti is a 110-proof wheated bourbon made to be an homage to the medicinal whiskeys produced at the distillery.

“We stand behind our motto, ‘Honor Tradition, Embrace Change,’” said Harlen Wheatley, Buffalo Trace Master Distiller, in a press release. “Each of these brands disappeared slowly in the years after Prohibition, but they were integral to our survival. Without them, today there would be no Buffalo Trace, Eagle Rare, or Weller bourbons. The Prohibition Collection is a tribute to these great whiskeys from our past.”

The best part? Instead of buying one bottle and then not knowing whether or not it would be your favorite in the collection, you can buy a set featuring all five bottles. The custom-made wooden case features all five expressions in 375ml bottles (half the size of the average bottle). This is because, during Prohibition, bottles came in this size. Not only that, the case and bottles are adorned with Prohibition-era artwork and labels. The packaging stays true to its Prohibition medicinal history by featuring back cartons that can be cut out so you can give them to your doctor to apply for a whiskey prescription (although they might scratch their head if you use them).

Since this is a limited-edition, highly sought-after collection, it’s not cheap. Available at selected retailers, bars, and restaurants in the U.S. right now, the full collection retails for $999.99. That’s a high price to pay for some medicine. But you do you.

Learn More

Editors' Recommendations

Christopher Osburn
Christopher Osburn is a food and drinks writer located in the Finger Lakes Region of New York. He's been writing professional
Trader Joe’s has wine and food: Here’s how to pair the two
You don't want to make multiple stops at several stores anyway
Trader Joe's store

For ages, Trader Joe's has offered bargain groceries and its own line of tasty, ready-to-eat dishes. Turns out, the grocery chain has some decent wine options, too, most of which stay well below the $20 mark.

That got us thinking: Why aren't we pairing these items? Food and wine love each other and at a place like Trader Joe's (TJ's), you can come away with a great meal and accompanying wine that needs little more than to be heated up and poured into a glass, respectively.

Read more
Tequila aging terms, demystified: Everything you want (and need) to know
Do you know the difference between reposado and añejo tequila?
Tequila with lemons

Just like when it comes to whiskey, the aging process for tequila is extremely important. Although, unlike bourbon, rye, Japanese whisky, and even single malt Scotch whisky, tequila doesn’t follow the same aging rules. You won’t find a bottle that says Don Julio 12-Year or Cimarron 10-Year like you would in the whisk(e)y world. If you didn’t know any better, you might assume tequila bottles don’t carry any age statements at all. They do, but they just need a little more deciphering than their whiskey counterparts.

But tequila, like whiskey, needs (except for blanco tequila) to spend time aging in barrels. While unaged tequila carries the vegetal sweetness of the roasted agave and light flavors like honey and vanilla, maturation imparts extra aromas and flavors, thanks to the chemical processes that take place from resting and aging in charred oak barrels. Flavors and aromas of caramel, chocolate, and gentle spices are heightened by aging. The longer the maturation, the more pronounced the aromas and flavors will be.

Read more
Smooth, oaky reposado tequila options perfect for fall sipping
Try one of these smooth tequilas
Tequila

If you’re new to tequila, you might be confused by the aging terms. Instead of listing the months or years the tequila has aged, you’ll find terms like blanco, reposado, añejo, extra añejo, cristalino, and joven. We could spend a long time defining each one, but today is all about reposado.

For the uninitiated, reposado tequilas are matured between two and twelve months. The word translates from Spanish to English to mean “restful”. And while it’s not nearly as rested or aged as añejo (matured between one and three years), it still picks up a ton of aroma and flavor from the maturation process. We’re talking flavors like toasted vanilla beans, toffee, oak, and spices, as well as a roasted agave, vegetal sweetness throughout.

Read more